Things We Never Got Over Summary – A Journey of Love, Family, and Healing
Introduction: When the Past Refuses to Let Go
What happens when you try to run from your problems, only to land straight into chaos? That’s exactly what unfolds for Naomi Witt in Lucy Score’s bestselling romance, Things We Never Got Over. With her life upended, Naomi is mistaken for her troublemaking twin sister, thrust into small-town drama, and unexpectedly becomes the guardian of an eleven-year-old niece she never knew existed.
In this Things We Never Got Over Summary, we explore the deeply emotional, witty, and gripping tale of a woman who finds herself amid chaos—only to discover that love, family, and healing might just be waiting for her in the most unexpected places.
Quick Overview
- Genre: Contemporary Romance / Romantic Comedy
- Themes: Family, trauma, small-town life, second chances, emotional healing
- Audience: Readers who crave character-driven stories with emotional intensity and heartfelt romance
- Rating: 4.5/5
Plot Summary: From Runaway Bride to Reluctant Heroine
Naomi Witt arrives in Knockemout, Virginia, expecting a fresh start—but she immediately gets mistaken for her identical twin sister, Tina. With Tina notorious for stirring up trouble, Naomi quickly finds herself entangled in a web of misunderstandings, judgmental locals, and one very grumpy barber named Knox Morgan.
The confusion worsens when Naomi discovers Tina has vanished, leaving behind not just Naomi’s stolen car but also an eleven-year-old daughter named Waylay. Thrust into a parental role she never signed up for, Naomi must navigate this new life with grit and grace.
Knox, a rugged, tattooed man who values solitude and has his own scars, wants nothing to do with Naomi’s mess. Yet, as their lives continue to intertwine, the chemistry between them becomes impossible to ignore. Despite their differences, Naomi and Knox begin to rely on each other in ways neither expected.
Things We Never Got Over Summary – Chapter Highlights
- The Wrong Woman – Naomi’s mistaken identity creates immediate tension with Knox.
- Unexpected Niece – Naomi learns she has custody of Waylay, a smart but guarded girl.
- From Motel to Cottage – Knox steps in to help, despite his reluctance.
- The Town Reacts – Naomi navigates judgmental locals and takes a job at Knox’s bar.
- Growing Connections – Naomi and Waylay bond, and Knox’s icy demeanor begins to thaw.
- Stef to the Rescue – Naomi’s best friend shows up, adding humor and support.
- Tension and Intimacy – Romantic sparks fly between Naomi and Knox.
- Family Drama – Naomi’s estranged parents arrive, and the situation gets messier.
- Heartbreak and Realization – Knox pushes Naomi away, fearing commitment.
- Danger Strikes – Tina resurfaces, threatening Naomi and Waylay.
- Rescue and Redemption – Knox, Nash, and Lucian save the day, and love triumphs.
Character Arcs and Growth
- Naomi Witt transforms from a people-pleaser into a confident woman who embraces love and responsibility.
- Knox Morgan learns to lower his walls and face his trauma, opening himself to vulnerability.
- Waylay Witt blossoms under Naomi’s care, showcasing strength and intelligence far beyond her years.
- Tina Witt serves as the catalyst for Naomi’s transformation and the primary antagonist.
- Nash Morgan offers stability and insight, guiding Naomi through small-town life and family challenges.
Core Themes and Emotional Depth
| Theme | Explanation |
|---|---|
| Family | Explores both biological dysfunction and the support of chosen family in small-town dynamics. |
| Healing | Both Naomi and Knox navigate emotional wounds, slowly learning to trust and heal together. |
| Self-Discovery | Naomi finds her voice, setting boundaries, and choosing a life that fulfills her, not just others. |
| Romance | The central relationship showcases love as messy, healing, and ultimately transformative. |
| Community | Knockemout becomes an unexpected pillar of support for Naomi and Waylay. |
Lucy Score: The Author Behind the Magic
Lucy Score is renowned for crafting emotionally rich romances with humor, heart, and heat. Her Knockemout series, beginning with Things We Never Got Over, has become a fan-favorite on platforms like BookTok for its endearing characters and slow-burn romance.
Popular Works:
- Things We Hide from the Light (Nash’s story)
- Things We Left Behind (Lucian and Sloane)
- By a Thread, Rock Bottom Girl, The Worst Best Man (Standalone rom-coms)
Why Readers Love Her:
- Lovable, layered characters
- Slow-burn romance that feels authentic
- Quirky, cozy small-town settings
- Humor balanced with emotional intensity
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is this a standalone novel?
A: Yes, though it’s the first in a connected series set in Knockemout.
Q: Who should read this book?
A: Fans of heartfelt romances, small-town drama, and stories about emotional growth.
Q: What makes this book unique?
A: The mix of humor, high stakes, rich character arcs, and authentic emotion.
Conclusion: Why You Should Read Things We Never Got Over
Things We Never Got Over Summary isn’t just about romance—it’s about finding strength in chaos, creating a family out of broken pieces, and learning that love often shows up when you least expect it.
Lucy Score has crafted a story that resonates emotionally, entertains deeply, and leaves readers rooting for its characters long after the final page. Whether you’re drawn in by the grumpy-sunshine romance, the small-town charm, or the gripping personal transformations, Naomi and Knox’s journey is sure to captivate your heart.
Get your copy of Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score and dive into the heartfelt world of Knockemout.
Books to Thrive – Book Summaries That Matter
